People talk
Our Guestbook
“ The pizzas are always great. The staff is always helpful. Pricing isn’t too bad either. There is no inside dining, but there are plenty of spaces to park for curbside pickup. ”
“ Favorite pizza ever! No walk up service, order ahead pickup only. The pizza is classic Indiana style. If there is a style of Indiana pizza this would be it. Chopped toppings, everything seems chopped; square cuts with four little corner pieces that the family can fight over. ”
“ Best pizza that I have had from there in a long time. ”
“ Four stars because didn't know I could go in and place my order...the inside is under construction and the phone was having issues (State Street location). I was told by Arni's staff the restaurant portion will be opening in a month or so. That is great news! It is so difficult to drive all the way home without eating those small, little, bite size triangles around the edges of the pizza...perfect for nibbling at red light stops lol...arriving home with a whole pizza is impossible. I love Arni's pizza and have since I was a young girl...the flavor stays consistent and is unique. ”
“ This place is amazing! It’s always been amazing. If you like the pizza you love the pizza and the consistency has been going on for at least 30 years. It’s what Pizza King used to be 20 years ago ”
“ Its a small place but man they are creative with the pizza!!! Love the spin you put on your pizzas and I love how excited you get about them as well. ”
“ The dining room is not open. Carry out only. The pizza is great! Took about 25 minutes from the time we ordered until it was in the car. They are busy even on a Monday night. We spent 18 on a large 3 topping pizza. ”
“ Great food and atmosphere for the family! I have absolutely loved this place ever since I was a kid! ”
About
Arni's New Albany
If you find yourself in New Albany, Indiana, be sure to stop by Arni's New Albany, a beloved local pizzeria known for its distinct Indiana-style pizzas. Nestled at 1208 State St, this gem has become a staple for both locals and visitors alike. With a strong reputation built over decades, the excitement and loyalty surrounding Arni's is palpable.
Arni's has mastered the art of pizza-making with its signature style. Customers rave about the chopped toppings and classic square cuts, which feature four irresistible corner pieces—perfect for sharing among family or friends. As noted by regulars, the pizza not only boasts a unique flavor but also maintains remarkable consistency, making it a reliable choice for pizza lovers. One long-time fan, Revbruceiv, puts it succinctly: “It’s always been amazing.”
While Arni's currently offers curbside pickup only, the anticipation of their indoor dining reopening soon adds to the excitement. Recent feedback has highlighted how essential the outdoor spaces for parking are, making it easy to grab a delicious meal from this fantastic establishment. What’s more, many patrons, like Yakky Doodle, recall fond memories of enjoying the delightful “bite-size triangles” from the edges of the pizza, making the experience even more nostalgic.
The affordability of their offerings does not go unnoticed either. Alex Hunnicutt commended the pricing, further enhancing Arni's appeal as a go-to spot for families and friends looking for a meal that won’t break the bank. As the buzz around Arni's new dining expansion grows, now is the perfect time to savor their iconic pizzas that continue to satisfy for over 30 years.
In a nutshell, Arni's New Albany is more than just a pizza place; it’s a community hub where flavors unite families and friends in joyful moments. Whether you are a lifelong fan or a first-time visitor, Arni's is a slice of Indiana tradition that promises to warm your heart and fill your stomach.
Book a table